Monday briefing: What did we learn at Your Party’s first conference?
Good morning. Over the weekend the new left-wing party being built by Jeremy Corbyn, Zarah Sultana and their supporters held its first conference. It came after months of public in-fighting and factional disputes, and in the wake of two independent MPs quitting the project before it even had a name. In the end, the main announcement proved somewhat underwhelming – with the party sticking with the bound-to-get-confusing moniker Your Party. But the decision to have a form of collective leadership, rather than face what threatened to be a bitter contest between Corbyn and Sultana for the top job, may prove ultimately more consequential. Sultana’s refusal to attend on Saturday, in solidarity with delegates expelled over links to other parties, suggested the in-fighting isn’t over. I spoke to Geraldine McKelvie, a senior correspondent for the Guardian, who attended the conference on Saturday, about the party’s chaotic start, its still-emerging policy platform, and the danger that it may already have been outflanked by Zack Polanski’s surging Green party. Before that, here are the headlines. Five big stories Politics | Labour’s economic plan will take years to deliver in full, Keir Starmer has said as he tries to regain the narrative after a turbulent response to last week’s budget. In an article for the Guardian, the prime minister hit back at his political opponents, insisting the chancellor, Rachel Reeves, was right to impose £26bn worth of tax rises. Bangladesh | A Bangladesh court has sentenced MP and former minister Tulip Siddiq to two years in jail, in a corruption case involving the alleged illegal allocation of a plot of land. Siddiq has denied the allegations and the trial was conducted in her absence. Ukraine | Ukrainian negotiators have met US officials in Florida to thrash out details of Washington’s proposed framework to end Russia’s war in Ukraine, as Kyiv faces pressure on military and political fronts. Israel | Benjamin Netanyahu has asked Israel’s president for a pardon for bribery and fraud charges and an end to a five-year corruption trial, arguing that it would be in the “national interest”. Extreme weather | Sri Lanka and Indonesia have deployed military personnel to help victims of devastating flooding that has killed nearly 1,000 people across four countries in Asia in recent days. In depth: Your Party’s moment of truth
Hundreds of thousands of people immediately signed up to join the Your Party mailing list when plans for the party were first announced back in July, and 2,500 delegates gathered in Liverpool over the weekend for the inaugural conference. “It feels odd to put a number on support for a party that didn’t formally have a name yet,” Geraldine McKelvie told me. We are so far out from the likely date of the next general election as to render polling figures akin to reading tea leaves, but recent YouGov numbers suggested about 12% of voters would consider backing Your Party – a sign that a sizeable chunk of the left remains dismayed by the direction of Keir Starmer’s government. *** Chaos from the start and splits in the ranks The party did not get off to a great start. Back in September, a moment that should have been celebratory: Zarah Sultana’s public announcement that she was leaving Labour to co-lead a new left-wing party with Jeremy Corbyn – quickly turned sour. The problem, it turned out, was that Corbyn and his allies had not yet committed to the project. Instead of keeping quiet, they began briefing this to the press. This moment, Geraldine told me, was such a bad start to the project that it’s now known internally as “terrible Thursday”. Then came the misfiring tech side of the launch. “Sultana set up a membership portal, collected a lot of personal data and membership fees, and Corbyn’s team were really unhappy about that, as she seemed to have done it off her own bat”, said Geraldine. The money has subsequently seemed to be in limbo – but the headlines the story generated, plus the vibe of financial mismanagement and general incompetence, have not been good for the party. Peter Walker teed up the conference on Friday with an in-depth piece worth reading, that sums up the debacle of the party’s origins: “At one point we had six MPs and four different factions.” Two of the MPs who initially backed the project – Blackburn MP Adnan Hussain and Dewsbury and Batley MP Iqbal Mohamed – have since split away “They said the atmosphere was toxic and not inclusive enough,” Geraldine said. “They were among a cohort of independent MPs elected in 2024 in areas with a large Muslim population standing almost on a pro-Gaza single-issue ticket. “They tend to be quite culturally conservative, whereas many new Your Party members are very progressive on issues like transgender rights. Finding a consensus between those groups will be a challenge.” *** A different kind of conference The weekend in Liverpool was promoted as a very different type of conference. Instead of delegates being appointed by local party branches – which don’t exist yet – people were selected to attend by sortition, a system akin to random jury service, but weighted to make the hall broadly representative of the membership.
But supporters of one particular Your Party member dominate. “The party is built around Jeremy Corbyn’s appeal. Without him, would people still be attracted to it?” asked Geraldine. And that presents its own problems: Corbyn is 76 now, and could be 80 come the next election – and while Corbyn might still have a political appetite by then, it’s also hard to predict. Going into the weekend’s conference was unlike covering other political gatherings, Geraldine said. “By Thursday evening there was still no programme. I still didn’t know what debates were happening when. I’d been chasing advisers for details. All I knew was that there would be a few debates and some amendments voted on – but not what the subjects were.” *** What did conference decide? “We have a party, we have rules, we have a constitution, we have enthusiasm, we have commitment, we have principles. And, above all, we have a name,” Corbyn said yesterday as it was revealed that given the options Your Party, Our Party, Popular Alliance and For The Many, 37% of members had opted to stay with what they know. The more significant outcome longer term was a narrow vote for ‘“collective leadership”. A new member-led executive will take the big decisions around the party’s management and strategy, with a chair, deputy chair and spokesperson helping to provide public leadership. It may be a very public symbol of doing politics differently, but it isn’t a structure the British voting public are yet familiar with. It was the option that Sultana had spoken in favour of – and avoids any chance of a messy leadership contest in the near future. In what appeared to be another win for Sultana’s view of the party’s future there was also a vote in favour of allowing members to hold dual membership of other political groups. Sultana had refused to attend on Saturday after delegates were expelled over links to other leftwing parties. She had described that as a “witch-hunt”, even as Corbyn was supportive of the decision. *** The threat from the Greens While Your Party attempts to get itself organised, the Zack Polanski-led Green party of England and Wales – the Scottish Greens are a separate entity – appears to have marched firmly on to the turf of the progressive left. Geraldine thinks the Greens’ current momentum is a major strategic threat to the success of Your Party. The numbers here are telling; the Green party now has more members than the Conservatives, and has been left wondering how to spend a huge cash windfall of £4m from new members (£), and it also seems to have eaten up a huge swathe of voters who have turned off Your Party. That could be good news for the left, but it’s certainly bad news for Your Party. “Left-wing politics often has a reputation for being quite factional,” Geraldine reminded me, adding “but Your Party seems to be the epitome of that already, and it’s not even a year old. That may put a lot of the electorate off.” *** The road ahead The party has left itself a great deal of work to do if it wants to contest the Scottish parliament, Welsh Senedd and English local elections in May 2026, and will announce a decision on its plans for those shortly. Reform UK’s troubles with off-piste MPs and councillors since the 2024 general election have ably demonstrated how difficult it is for a new(ish) party to vet a large slate of candidates in a hurry. “They’ve been deliberately very light on policy,” Geraldine said. “But beyond the Gaza issue that some of the independents were elected on, it’s not clear what the party stands for. Members want it to be member-led, but before the next election voters will want to know what they’re actually offering.” And once a platform emerges, it carries risks. “There’s a danger,” Geraldine said, “that if their policies are too out of line with the British public on things like Nato – where barely 8% support an exit – soft-left Labour voters disillusioned with Starmer might find it easier to protest-vote Lib Dem as a more moderate option.” Whether any of the weekend’s decisions in Liverpool brought clarity – or merely added new layers of factional argument – is something Your Party members may still be working out today. What else we’ve been reading
Simon Hattenstone’s interview with Jessie J is good on so many levels. First of all, it gave me closure about that time she left her long-term relationship with a woman and then referred to it as “just a phase”. But I was also just amazed at her optimism and resilience. Poppy Noor, newsletters team The full scale of the Trump cash-machine is laid bare by Tom Burgis, and while you may think you know the story – the frenzy of deal making is still shocking. Toby Moses, newsletters team Zoe Williams on the tactics we can all use to resist hard-line governments is a rousing, heartening lesson in philosophy and community organising. Poppy Has the UK reached peak pizza? Sarah Butler examines the biggest question of our age, after the news last week that the chief exec of Domino’s was stepping down shortly after having suggested a pivot to fried chicken. Toby I loved our infographic on the sex lives of gen Z, which I knew nothing about prior! Poppy Sport
Football | Premier League leaders Arsenal were held 1-1 at Stamford Bridge, despite Chelsea going down to 10 men in the 38th minute when Moisés Caicedo was sent off for a horrible challenge on Mikel Merino, pictured above. The Spanish international went on to score the equaliser. Formula One | Max Verstappen won the Qatar Grand Prix, ensuring the title will go down to the final race in Abu Dhabi. Rugby union | Bath won 36-29 at Saracens, despite having been 14-0 down, with Henry Arundell scoring two tries. The front pages
The fallout from the budget continues, as the Guardian leads with “PM says bold plan will take years to deliver as he hits back at critics”. The Times headline is “Ministers: Reeves misled us over hole in finances”, while the Telegraph says “Reeves faces ethics probe over Budget lies”. The Mail reports “Farage: Reeves must face sleaze probe over Budget lies”. The i has “I didn’t lie about Budget tax rises and black hole, insists Reeves”. The Financial Times headlines “Nato chiefs weigh ‘more aggressive’ response to Russian hybrid warfare”. Finally the Mirror kicks off its Christmas appeal with “A lifeline to the world”. Today in Focus
The women throwing off their hijabs in Tehran Social media videos of women riding motorbike and dancing in the streets in the Islamic Republic have gone viral. But after war, and the crushing of the ‘Women, life, freedom’ movement what is life really like? Deepa Parent reports. Cartoon of the day | Tom Gauld
The Upside A bit of good news to remind you that the world’s not all bad
At 85, Sir Cliff Richard is out on the road again – because, despite being exiled from pop’s mainstream, he’s outlasted his contemporaries. Last week, he finished a run of shows in Australia and New Zealand. He was the artist who opened the British rock’n’roll era, with Move It in 1958 – and the UK leg of his Can’t Stop Me Now tour – opening in Cardiff – is finishing at the Royal Albert Hall on 9 December. After 67 years he is still selling out big rooms, despite being shunned from the radio long ago. So what’s behind his enduring appeal? To the uninitiated, Sir Cliff’s continued presence in the music space is, at best, a mystery, and at worst an affront to taste. That is to misunderstand him: because Sir Cliff doesn’t so much operate in the music business as he does in the Cliff Richard business. Sign up here for a weekly roundup of The Upside, sent to you every Sunday Bored at work? And finally, the Guardian’s puzzles are here to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow. Quick crossword Cryptic crossword Wordiply